Facial Detection Cameras in Digital Ads Near Toronto's Union Station Scanned Commuters Without Informed Consent for Three Years
Cameras embedded in advertising screens scanned 250,000+ daily Toronto commuters for three years before attracting public attention.
Beginning in approximately late 2022, Cineplex Digital Media installed digital advertising screens equipped with small cameras in the entryway to the Bus Terminal at Toronto's Union Station — located within Canada's busiest multi-modal transit hub, which serves an estimated 250,000–300,000 people daily. The cameras used Quividi's AVA audience measurement software to detect faces in real time, estimate each viewer's age range and gender using neural networks, and dynamically select which advertisement to display based on the inferred demographics (CP24, 2025-11-08; Rogers Cybersecure Catalyst, 2025).
The screens operated for approximately three years with no public awareness. A small disclaimer embedded in the displays stated that "anonymous software" generated "statistics about audience counts, gender and approximate age only" and that "no images and no data unique to an individual person is recorded." On November 2, 2025, a Reddit user posted a photo on r/Toronto showing the camera and disclaimer, sparking immediate public concern and media coverage (Global News, 2025-11-05).
Five days after the Reddit post went viral, on November 7, 2025, Cineplex Inc. completed the sale of its digital media division to Creative Realities Inc. (CRI), a US-based digital signage company, for C$70 million — a deal that had been announced earlier. CRI did not respond to media inquiries about the facial detection controversy (Global News, 2025-11-05).
Grassroots advocacy organization Technologists for Democracy, co-signed by OpenMedia and transit advocacy groups, filed a formal complaint with the Office of the Privacy Commissioner (Toronto Today, 2025). On December 8, 2025, Privacy Commissioner Philippe Dufresne opened an investigation into whether the technology complies with PIPEDA (CP24, 2025-12-08; Global News, 2025-12-08; NOW Toronto, 2025; Sixteen-Nine, 2025).
The case has notable parallels to the 2020 Cadillac Fairview case. Cadillac Fairview used the same type of AVA technology in mall kiosks, made similar claims that "no personal information" was collected and images were "deleted immediately," and the OPC investigation found these claims to be misleading — over five million facial representations had in fact been captured and retained (OPC, 2020). Privacy experts have noted that corporate self-attestation about data deletion was found to be misleading in the Cadillac Fairview case (OPC, 2020), and have questioned whether meaningful consent is achievable in a transit corridor where commuters cannot practically avoid the technology (Rogers Cybersecure Catalyst, 2025).
As of March 2026, the OPC investigation remains active, no screens have been reported removed, and Creative Realities has not made a public statement addressing the controversy.
Materialized From
Harms
Digital advertising screens equipped with cameras captured and analyzed the faces of commuters passing through the Union Station Bus Terminal entryway — part of a hub serving an estimated 250,000–300,000 people daily to estimate their age and gender and dynamically target advertisements, without meaningful informed consent. The screens operated for approximately three years before public discovery.
A small disclaimer on the screens was the only notice provided. No opt-in consent mechanism existed, and commuters had no practical way to avoid the cameras while using the transit corridor — an environment where meaningful consent may not be achievable.
Evidence
9 reports
- 'I didn't sign up for this': Facial detecting ads near Toronto's Union Station raise concerns Primary source
Global News reporting: facial detecting ads near Toronto's Union Station; initial disclosure and public reaction
- Privacy commissioner launches investigation after facial detection ads pop up in Toronto Primary source
CP24 reporting: privacy commissioner launches investigation after facial detection technology found at Union Station advertising screens
-
Global News follow-up: privacy commissioner probing facial detection ads near Union Station; investigation launch
-
Precedent case involving same AVA technology where OPC found claims of no data collection to be misleading
-
CP24 explainer: what to know about the ads that could be recording you near Union Station; technical details of the system
-
Expert analysis of privacy implications and consent issues
-
Toronto Today reporting: advocates demand answers about billboards with facial detection technology; documents public advocacy response
-
NOW Toronto reporting: privacy watchdog investigating controversial facial recognition advertising screens; community response
-
Sixteen-Nine (digital signage trade press): Canada opens privacy probe into DooH screens near Union Station; industry perspective
Record details
Responses & Outcomes
Opened formal investigation into privacy concerns related to digital signs near Union Station that use facial detection software, examining PIPEDA compliance
Editorial Assessment assessed
Undisclosed facial detection technology operated for approximately three years in one of Canada's busiest transit corridors — scanning commuters at a hub serving an estimated 250,000–300,000 people daily — before a Reddit user noticed a small camera and disclaimer (Global News, 2025; CP24, 2025). The technology and corporate claims are similar to the Cadillac Fairview case, where the same type of AVA technology and similar assurances of "no data stored" were found by the OPC to be misleading (Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada, 2020). The OPC investigation is ongoing and has not yet issued findings on this case (CP24, 2025; Global News, 2025). The case involves the question of whether meaningful consent is possible in a transit environment where people cannot practically avoid the technology (Rogers Cybersecure Catalyst, 2025).
Entities Involved
AI Systems Involved
The facial detection and audience measurement software embedded in digital advertising screens, using cameras to capture faces and estimate demographics in real time to select targeted advertisements
Related Records
- Cadillac Fairview Collected Five Million Shopper Images Using Undisclosed Facial Recognition in Canadian Mallsrelated
- Canadian Tire Deployed Facial Recognition to Identify Shoppers in British Columbia Storesrelated
Taxonomyassessed
Changelog
| Version | Date | Change |
|---|---|---|
| v1 | Mar 8, 2026 | Initial publication |
| v2 | Mar 11, 2026 | Verification upgraded from corroborated to confirmed: OPC issued formal PIPEDA findings (#2020-004) on the underlying surveillance practice. |
| v3 | Mar 12, 2026 | Neutrality/factuality review: clarified that 250,000–300,000 daily figure is for Union Station overall, not the Bus Terminal entryway specifically; removed 3 policy recommendations that generalized Cadillac Fairview-specific OPC findings into general prescriptions, per CAIM neutrality policy. |